A Tavern Built for Avenel
Caroline's Tavern opened on Avenel Street and the neighborhood claimed it almost immediately. Pull up a chair — this is your place too.
Caroline's Tavern | Our Story
A Tavern Avenel Made Its Own
From day one, locals skipped the full name and just called it Caroline's — that kind of shorthand is earned, not given. We built this place to feel like a neighborhood living room: warm, a little buzzy, and always happy to see you.
Comfort Food, Done With Real Craft
Smashburgers stacked high, sticky sesame ribs, Tavern Mac, Fruity Pebble Tres Leches — and a chef who'll build custom dishes for any dietary need, no questions asked.
The Bar Means Business
From PB&J Old Fashioneds to boozy milkshakes and a BLT Bloody Mary at brunch — plus happy hour Monday–Friday 3–6 PM.
Next Door to the Arts Center
Steps from the Avenel Performing Arts Center, Caroline's is the perfect pre-show dinner or post-curtain gathering — and the Theater Room is available for private events.
The Team Behind the Tavern
Brought to you by Bread and Butter Hospitality — the NJ/NY group behind The Stone House, Violette's, Sofia's Taqueria, and more.